The focus of the discussion was exploring the potential to organize a debate or panel to discuss the controversial Bitcoin SV proposals of the Network Access Rules (NAR) and Digital Asset Recovery (DAR). These proposals had surfaced differing opinions within the BSV community, as evidenced by a poll showing the community split around 50/50 on supporting or opposing them. The NAR relates to formalizing network rules and requiring honest node behavior, which had general support in principle from the participants, seeing it as a necessity for governance. However, the DAR component involving asset recovery and arbitration capabilities received more objections, seen by some as potentially undermining decentralization principles, transaction finality, and jurisdictional authority.

Multiple potential panelists were suggested, covering both supporters and critics of the proposals. Supporters included Connor Murray, Kurt Wuckert Jr, Brian DY, Brett, and BSV Panama. Potential critics included Michael Scott, Ian Grigg, Crypto Voyager, and Cub. A wide range of issues were debated during the open discussion, including the need for oversight versus adhering to decentralization, the risks of enabling transaction "clawbacks", determining authority over jurisdictions and legal enforceability, whether NAR and DAR should be associated together or separated, execution challenges witnessed in practice with other blockchain projects, the need for education on benefits, and the appropriate role of the Bitcoin Association.

Apart from the specific debate proposals, the conversation also touched on broader themes like Bitcoin SV's approach to regulation, ecosystem growth, and usefulness for applications beyond just payments. By the end, the group agreed that assembling panels to openly discuss and debate these issues could be highly valuable for the community to air all perspectives and make informed decisions. The conversation demonstrated the nuances in governance required in building a blockchain ecosystem and highlighted opportunities for education, transparency, and responsible enforcement.

Network Access Rules:
[ Ссылка ]

To NAR or Not to NAR? #xTownHall Sparring Over BitcoinSV's Governance
[ Ссылка ]

Subscribe ➜ [ Ссылка ]

@gavinmehl x
@gavingmehl IG
Gavin917
00:00:00 Introduction to Network Access Rules
00:22:53 Objections to Network Access Rules
01:00:59 Proponents of Network Access Rules
01:17:26 BSV Panama
01:20:02 Objections to DAR Digital Access Recovery
01:38:28 Gregory Ward - Smart Ledger
02:24:07 Brett Banfe - BitcoinSV - Community Director
02:31:18 Bryan Daugherty - Regulation - Lobbying Efforts

свернуть