Arthur knew she was most likely BS’ing the whole “I ratted” thing because of the way she was acting all the months leading up to that moment when ms grinshaw shot her. He was the only one to be concerned enough about her behavior and really the only one who ever payed her any mind. Everyone took her word for it when Arthur knew all she wanted was Dutch’s attention. He didn’t immediately write her off as being the rat, because he knew there was a possibility. But just enough doubt for him to want to convince Dutch not to kill her #rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/JGV-MqlPEYM/maxresdefault.jpg)