I removed all other weapons so that I would only show the ones required for the Knight's Honor trophy.

I have a few useful tips to give for this trophy because the guides don't do it.

I can guarantee that, at least in the latest (1.03) PS4 version, the trophy remembers previously held weapons. I placed everything I had in my storage box into my direct inventory, then dropped every weapon (except for two I would ascend into my last needed weapons), quit and reloaded to make sure the weapons on the floor despawned, then got the last two weapons via ascension, and the trophy unlocked! Even though I had disposed of ALL other weapons.
(I had made a backup save before doing this just in case; I'm not crazy)

The official trophy guide's list of required weapons is incomplete, and the weapons are listed in a random order with slight misspellings that add up to the confusion, when you consider how similarly some weapons are named. However, it is possible to arrange your weapons in a fixed order, so that, when cross-referenced to a proper list, allows you to track your weapons a LOT easier. To get your weapons in the default order, transfer all of them from the bottomless box to your direct inventory (hold Down on the dpad and L1 to do it in less than 10 seconds). Then on your weapons tab, press X on any weapon and "Reset Order". This option doesn't just mix them up. It puts them in a proper, universal order that is always the same. If I remember correctly, I based this list on the Knight's Honor wikidot guide.

Here are all the needed weapons (in-game order and spelling):

Priscilla's Dagger
Silv. Knight Str. Sword
Astora's Straight Sword
Drake Sword
Black Knight Sword
Stone Greatsword
Greatsword of Artorias (Cursed)
Greatsword of Artorias (Normal)
Great Lord Greatsword
Moonlight Greatsword
Black Knight Greatsword
Dragon Greatsword
Quelaag's Furysword
Gravelord Sword
Chaos Blade
Velka's Rapier
Gargoyle Tail Axe
Crescent Axe
Golem Axe
Black Knight Greataxe
Dragon King Greataxe
Grant
Dragon Tooth
Smough's Hammer
Channeler's Trident
Silver Knight Spear
Moonlight Butterfly Horn
Dragonslayer Spear
Giant's Halberd
Black Knight Halberd
Lifehunt Scythe
Dragon Bone Fist
Dark Hand
Dragonslayer Greatbow
Darkmoon Bow
Tin Darkmoon Catalyst
Effigy Shield
Crystal Ring Shield
Sanctus
Bloodshield
Crest Shield
Dragon Crest Shield
Silver Knight Shield
Black Knight Shield
Black Iron Greatshield
Stone Greatshield
Havel's Greatshield
Greatshield of Artorias

I only added the parentheses in the two Greatswords of Artorias because, although they count as different weapons, they both have the exact same name.
Here is how to tell them apart:

The *normal variant* is the white sword whose item description (which is only viewable when you actually carry the weapon) ends with *"against dark servants",* and whose original starting stats (that will only change if you upgrade it after getting it), as they appear on a blacksmith's "Modify Equipment" menu before you get it, are *120-85-0-0.*
The *cursed variant* is the black sword whose item description ends with *"creatures of the Abyss",* and whose original stats are *178-0-0-0.*

I'd like to help my brother for helping me rearrange the list at my request. It took us more than half an hour and he never played a Souls game.

свернуть