This is a tier list of nine of the largest and most active Youtube history channels, based on criticism at r/badhistory and other platforms, and what I consider to be best history Youtuber practice. Channels scored C or D can still be useful for learning history; they just don't do it as well as I think they should. Channels scored E or F should be avoided, in my opinion.
__________________________
Timestamps
0:00 Start
00:07 Introduction
11:39 Simple History [some bad history, oversimplification, plagiarism, insufficient sources]
15:38 Extra Credits [bad history, plagiarism, insufficient sources]
24:45 Kraut [bad history, strong political bias, insufficient sources]
31:06 Overly Sarcastic Productions [bad history, insufficient sources]
37:10 Kings & Generals [bad history, insufficient sources]
45:39 HomeTeam History [some bad history, speculation, some bad sources]
1:00:49 Whatifalthist [very bad history, strong political bias, insufficient sources, racism]
1:15:53 History Buffs [bad history, strong political bias, lack of sources]
1:22:11 Mark Felton [bad history, plagiarism]
1:28:05 Channels I didn't cover [not a history channel, too small, lack of activity, lack of presence on r/badhistory]
1:36:12 Conclusion
_______________________
Discord
[ Ссылка ]
_______________________
Patreon | [ Ссылка ]
_______________________
Sources
[ Ссылка ]
_______________________
Videos cited
Creating content: Making content accessible
[ Ссылка ]
Should YouTube Historians Be Held to the Same Standards as Academic Historians?
[ Ссылка ]
The Monsieur Z/Emperor Tigerstar Incident (All Tweets & Full Analysis)
[ Ссылка ]
Response to HomeTeam History on the Ishango & Lebombo bones #1 | arithmetic & symbolic numeracy
[ Ссылка ]
Response to HomeTeam History on the Ishango & Lebombo bones #2 | Lunar calendars
[ Ссылка ]
__________________________
Recommended channels
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
__________________________
Relevant subreddits
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
__________________________
Media sources
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]

свернуть